Let it be known that Monster and 20th Century Boys are, in my book, both top notch manga. So when I discovered that Naoki Urasawa's newest manga, Billy Bat, had begun being scanalated and posted on OneManga I jumped on the opportunity to read it. The verdict? It's not bad, but it's disappointing.
The series starts on a good foot. The first chapter and a half detail a story of Billy Bat. It's a pulpy late 40's detective comic. Our hero is a private eye bat hired by a dog to see if his wife is cheating, and of course he gets pulled into a web of lies and murder. This is an excellent homage. It feels natural, it looks authentic, it flows well, and it's interesting. I thought that this was an indication of amazing quality to come. Well, not so much.
Halfway through the second chapter, the coloring becomes sporadic and looks unfinished, a few panels become sketchy and we're pulled out of Billy Bat's world and into the world of it's author.
Kevin Yamagata is a Japanese-American comic artist drawing Billy Bat, which we are told is a vastly popular comic. However, soon after we meet him he's accused of plagiarizing a comic from the land of Japan. Bearing an overwhelming sense of the importance of intellectual property, Kevin feels he must track down the mangaka of this comic artist and apologize for subconsciously stealing his work. And so Kevin departs for Japan where he too get's entangled in a web of conspiracy and danger. And slowly we come to realize this Bat is more than just a comic character...
And so the story goes, and you can tell it's Urasawa. But it's also not as good as I'd expect from Urasawa. When I read Monster I loved the art. I was amazed at how he drew people. Then I read 20th Century Boy and a lot of characters looked way too familiar. With Billy Bat it's starting to get old. While the artwork of the comic within a comic was stellar and fresh, the main story's characters look recycled and forgettable. It doesn't stop at their looks either, their personalities are uncultivated too. None of the characters stick with you, which is a total shame because character writing and design were two of the biggest strengths of his previous works.
At the same time the story also feels like Urasawa is slipping into old habits. I get it, mysterious people are bad and ominous and the hero has to go on the lam to stop them. It worked twice before, right? Well it turns out the third time's not a charm. Billy Bat's storytelling feels disjointed. The thick dramatic atmosphere of Monster and 20th Century Boys is missing. Johan and Friend were both ominous and threatening to the point that the mere mention of their characters caused you to tense up a bit. Billy Bat doesn't really have that going. There's apparently some sort of conspiracy involving gold bars and taking over Japan, but it's vague and fairly non-threatening. Also, it's hard to find "Karate-Chop Man" to be threatening when it sounds so goofy. Furthermore, it's sort of suggested that Billy Bat himself is a paranormal entity, or maybe two. One of them's bad, but the other one not so much. We're told the difference is that that there's a black one and a white one but they look the same. Even if you could tell when it's the bad one, he's so cartoony and smug, it would be hard to find him menacing.
14 chapters in Urasawa pulls an Urasawa and jumps away from the main storyline. But instead of jumping to something that you'd think would somehow tie directly into the main plotline, a subplot about a minor character who hasn't met Kevin yet, but will as the arc draws to a close for example, it's a story about Jesus. It wasn't particularly illuminating to the story, and seemed mildly inappropriate. The story jumps forward in time for a short few chapters about a taxi driver that reunited an interracial couple in the middle of a civil rights demonstration. and then jumps back in time to 16th century Iga. These gaidens don't really feel like they have purpose or direction, and it's where the last translated chapter ends.
Final Judgement: It feels like this is Urasawa in a rut, retreading old territory but instead of doing it deliberately and artistically like he has in the past, he's doing it halfheartedly and sloppily. The story trashes about trying hard but failing to establish atmosphere, and not even really trying to establish characters. I'm sticking with it because I like Urasawa, but so far I'm pretty underwhelmed.
The series starts on a good foot. The first chapter and a half detail a story of Billy Bat. It's a pulpy late 40's detective comic. Our hero is a private eye bat hired by a dog to see if his wife is cheating, and of course he gets pulled into a web of lies and murder. This is an excellent homage. It feels natural, it looks authentic, it flows well, and it's interesting. I thought that this was an indication of amazing quality to come. Well, not so much.
Halfway through the second chapter, the coloring becomes sporadic and looks unfinished, a few panels become sketchy and we're pulled out of Billy Bat's world and into the world of it's author.
Kevin Yamagata is a Japanese-American comic artist drawing Billy Bat, which we are told is a vastly popular comic. However, soon after we meet him he's accused of plagiarizing a comic from the land of Japan. Bearing an overwhelming sense of the importance of intellectual property, Kevin feels he must track down the mangaka of this comic artist and apologize for subconsciously stealing his work. And so Kevin departs for Japan where he too get's entangled in a web of conspiracy and danger. And slowly we come to realize this Bat is more than just a comic character...
And so the story goes, and you can tell it's Urasawa. But it's also not as good as I'd expect from Urasawa. When I read Monster I loved the art. I was amazed at how he drew people. Then I read 20th Century Boy and a lot of characters looked way too familiar. With Billy Bat it's starting to get old. While the artwork of the comic within a comic was stellar and fresh, the main story's characters look recycled and forgettable. It doesn't stop at their looks either, their personalities are uncultivated too. None of the characters stick with you, which is a total shame because character writing and design were two of the biggest strengths of his previous works.
At the same time the story also feels like Urasawa is slipping into old habits. I get it, mysterious people are bad and ominous and the hero has to go on the lam to stop them. It worked twice before, right? Well it turns out the third time's not a charm. Billy Bat's storytelling feels disjointed. The thick dramatic atmosphere of Monster and 20th Century Boys is missing. Johan and Friend were both ominous and threatening to the point that the mere mention of their characters caused you to tense up a bit. Billy Bat doesn't really have that going. There's apparently some sort of conspiracy involving gold bars and taking over Japan, but it's vague and fairly non-threatening. Also, it's hard to find "Karate-Chop Man" to be threatening when it sounds so goofy. Furthermore, it's sort of suggested that Billy Bat himself is a paranormal entity, or maybe two. One of them's bad, but the other one not so much. We're told the difference is that that there's a black one and a white one but they look the same. Even if you could tell when it's the bad one, he's so cartoony and smug, it would be hard to find him menacing.
14 chapters in Urasawa pulls an Urasawa and jumps away from the main storyline. But instead of jumping to something that you'd think would somehow tie directly into the main plotline, a subplot about a minor character who hasn't met Kevin yet, but will as the arc draws to a close for example, it's a story about Jesus. It wasn't particularly illuminating to the story, and seemed mildly inappropriate. The story jumps forward in time for a short few chapters about a taxi driver that reunited an interracial couple in the middle of a civil rights demonstration. and then jumps back in time to 16th century Iga. These gaidens don't really feel like they have purpose or direction, and it's where the last translated chapter ends.
Final Judgement: It feels like this is Urasawa in a rut, retreading old territory but instead of doing it deliberately and artistically like he has in the past, he's doing it halfheartedly and sloppily. The story trashes about trying hard but failing to establish atmosphere, and not even really trying to establish characters. I'm sticking with it because I like Urasawa, but so far I'm pretty underwhelmed.
Leave a comment

